Bengal versus Maharashtra,Beef and Hindu politicians

Posted bysubhasmitraPosted inUncategorized

  (A   comparison).

Subhas Mitra:  01 July 2025

*** (Beef here is not ‘meat’ but “crushing Hindu ethos and moral Values under the feet”).

Hinduism in Bengal:

Between 1203 and 1491 AD, all Bengal’s temples, Stupas, and education centres were destroyed and” Idol” worship was banned.

  1. In 1501, Raja Kangsa Narayan of Rajshahi (EB) restarted “Idol worshipping” and “Temple building” with DURGA PUJA inside a Temple. (Currently, we can see in Andhra Pradesh, Odisha and Varanasi).
  • 1757: Raja Nabakrishna Deb welcomed  “Robert Clive” (  European coloniser)  by holding a DURGA  Puja where Beef, Pork, Wine and women were said to have been served.
  • 1790: To overcome Durga Puja restrictions by the Kings/ Jaminder,  12 friends came together and organised BAROARI (public) Durga  Puja at  Guptipara, Hooghly, where the LAST  king of the Sen dynasty, Lakshmanasena ‘s descendants live. (Even today).  
  • 1870s: “Vande Mataram” was written by Bankim Chandra Chattopadhya, where he addresses our nation/country as Ma DURGA dashanhuja. Soon, revolutionaries used Durga Puja to stimulate the sentiment of common people towards nationalism.  (At present, WB govt. Stopped signing?)
  • 1893:  Sep 10, Bal Gangadhar Tilak launched the first public modern Ganapati festival in Pune, being impressed by the Durga Puja effects on common people.
  • 1902 March 24: The “Anushilan Samiti” was founded by Pramathanath Mitra in Calcutta for the practical application of SHAKTI, the Durga.
  • 1905:  Gopal Krishna Gokhale becomes Congress president. He was amazed to see that in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Bengal was a major centre of intellectual and cultural renaissance in India. It was a hub of reform movements, nationalist ideas, and literary and artistic innovation. He said: What Bengal think today, India thinks a day after.
  • 1905: Rishi Arobindo Ghosh writes an 18-page pamphlet, “ Bhavani Mandir”. That attracted many youth, including Hedgewar.  Later, it became the basis of RSS propagation.
  • 1909: Shyama Prasad Mukherjee, family, Author Premendra Mitra, Arobindo etc. founded the FIRST Baroari Durga puja under Bhowanipore Sanatan Dharmatsahini Sabha, banner in Kolkata.   
  1. 1910: Keshav Baliram Hedgewar, a medical student at CU, joined Anushilan Samiti.
  1. 1911: “Jana Gana Mana”, the Indian national anthem, was written by Rabindranath Tagore. It was first sung on December 28, 1911, at the Calcutta Session of the Indian National Congress.
  1. 1925: He leaves Congress and returns to Nagpur to start RSS with 4/5 kids on a Dassera Day, and one such kid is now ruling India as PM.

Maharashtra’s THREE major milestones of Hindu India were developed on the Bengal model.

  • Freedom Movement – Congress, etc.
  • Public Ganapati Puja
  • Prarthana Samaj:  Prarthana Samaj was founded by Atmaram Pandurang along with Waman Abaji Modak on 31 March 1867, when Keshub Chandra Sen visited Maharashtra.

Hindu dilution movement in Bengal:   

After 1050 years of non-Hindu rule, when the EIC took over, Bengal had 65.07% Hindu (IR)- in 2011-31.7%.

Disclaimer:

  1. I am not competent to analyse the Hindu Renaissance (HR) but I am entitled to guess.
  2. Like many Bongs, I do not think that I am Intelligent and others are fools.  I think the other way. Let them correct me.
  3. The HR is now replaced by “Indian Renaissance” in the wiki.
  4. Wiki says Raja Ram Mohan Roy is often called the “Father of the Indian Renaissance,” but I felt it was a Church of England (CE) project.

There could have been no Hindu Renascence without Willum Jones, Max Muller, Willum Carry, Henry Louis Vivian Derozio,  James Long, C.F. Andrews and many of them who came here from Europe after occupying India to REVIVE   PAGANISM, HEATHEN Culture for the improvement of Gentiles living?   Had that been true how world today have 35+% Christians?  How have 40+ civilisations been destroyed by Abrahamic expansionist forces? Most of the HR promoters/ activists were Evangelists.

The formation of “Brahma Samaj” was needed to discard Idolatry & Hindu Rituals that CE considered as superstitions.

(I do not know if you peel off an onion, what do you expect inside. I never try to peel a grape.)  

 What I understand: They wanted the Brahma Samaj to believe that “Fruit Juice” can be made available without planting a sapling, growing a tree or waiting for the season for the fruit.

However, here are some of the milestones for Modernisation or scientific Hinduism:  

  1. The 1757 Durga Puja that violates tradition (Parampara) and defies cultural values. By new PRABHUBHAKT Raja.
  2. Sophia Dobson Collet, in her book “Life and Letters of Raja Ram Mohan Roy” (1914) wrote (pp. 32- 35) that Mr. Willum Roscoe introduces RRR to Lord Brougham as a celebrated author of The Precept of Jesus and an illustrious and prime Hindu convert.  

Many refuse to believe Sophia Dobson, but they think the RRR statue stands in front of Bristol Cathedral in the UK as that of a Heathen Gentile. We are seeing a MAGA attitude towards Hindus in the USA.

A Note: I compare these scientific or Made in England Hinduism with the bitter gourd creeper that climbed the Neem Tree (Communism) between 1917 & 1925.   We are getting the taste.

  • 2015: Mamata Banerjee, WB, declares all meats are the same but never mentions pork. Earlier in parliament, she said, “Eating beef is my birthright”(?). All beef shifted came in 2011 in her favour and became CM.
  • CPIM Bikash Bhattacherjee Publically eats cooked Beef for votes, but it failed, yet they are sustaining on beef eaters of both communities, like in Kerala.
  • One Hindu MLA put a condom on the Shiv Linga, and she got elected with Hindu votes.
  • Another proven, discredited and expelled MP with a Hindu name abuses Ma Kali and Hinduism but wins the election with the Hindu vote.

Maharashtra:

  1. It is believed Haji Mastan, Dawood Ibrahim were created by Hindu leaders for Vote and notes.
  2. Abdul Rahman Antule was made Siddhi Binayak Trustee for “Electoral benefit”.
  3. Palghar, Hindu Sadhus killed by alleged Illegal infiltrators with the logistics provided by Evangelists. An advocate approaching the site for assessment was killed by a road accident, but NOTHING happened for fear of losing votes.

Now Bala sahib’s son, grandson son and nephew want to win the election by igniting a language war like TN Church parties. An ex-TN BJP leader’s daughter, along with Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen, is believed to be instigating Md Yunus of Bangladesh to massacre Hindus.  

My suggestion: All three should stand in public in front of a TV camera and eat Raw Beef. That may bring some luck.  

Published by subhasmitra

I am an Indian military veteran